Funny Responses to ‘How Did You Get My Number?’: Savage Comebacks

Mrs And The Misc may earn commission from the links on this page, but we only ever share brands that we love and trust.

Sarah Koch


So you’re chatting with someone new and things seem to be going well.
When suddenly, they ask “How did you get my number?”

Uh oh, you’re put on the spot! Don’t panic.

With some witty comebacks up your sleeve, you can keep things fun and playful.
Let’s explore some amusing responses you can give.

Witty Responses

“A ninja never reveals their secrets!”

This reply is delightfully playful and mysterious.
It suggests you used some sneaky tactics to track down their digits.
Playing up the mystery can pique their curiosity.

  • “I’m actually a secret agent and that’s classified information.”
  • “I have my ways…but I’ll never tell!”
  • “What number? I just randomly dialed and here we are!”
  • “I’m actually a psychic and I foresaw this phone call happening.”
  • “I may or may not have hired a private investigator…”
  • “Let’s just say there was some light hacking involved.”
  • “Would you believe me if I said I’m from the future?”
  • “It was technically your number that got me.”
  • “I’m still trying to figure that out myself!”
  • “I’m sworn to secrecy…it’s part of the Bro Code.”

Flirty Comebacks

“A little birdie gave it to me…maybe you gave my number to them?”

Ooh la la, this one is cheeky and flirtatious!
It playfully suggests they were interested enough to share their number.
A little light teasing can build fun sexual tension.

  • “My psychic powers told me you wanted me to call.”
  • “What can I say? I’m irresistible like that.”
  • “I used my Jedi mind tricks…surprised they worked!”
  • “Lucky guess? Though I had a feeling you’d answer.”
  • “It was destiny…we were just meant to connect.”
  • “Wow, you must be more popular than I thought!”
  • “I stumbled upon it written on a bathroom stall.”
  • “I make it my mission to get numbers from all the cuties.”
  • “Why so suspicious? Is your number top-secret?”
  • “Maybe you accidentally slipped it into my pocket…”

Silly Replies

“I got it from the same place I get all my numbers…the Number Store!”

Absolutely ridiculous and kids won’t even find this funny.
But leaning into the nonsense is part of the charm!
A silly comeback is perfect for keeping things lighthearted.

  • “I’m actually a telephone psychic. Your number just came to me.”
  • “What are you talking about? You’re the one who called me!”
  • “Would you believe I just started randomly pressing buttons?”
  • “My dog is outstanding at retrieving phone numbers.”
  • “I traded three magic beans for it from a traveling salesman.”
  • “I downloaded it after taking a random online number quiz.”
  • “I hired a skywriter to display it for me, didn’t you see?”
  • “The numbers just whispered the sequence into my ear.”
  • “Oh I’ve had your number for ages…in case of emergency!”
  • “I started leaving notes around town until you responded.”

Deflecting Responses

“You know, I’m not really sure. It’s been awhile!”

Sometimes playing it cool is the smoothest move.
This relaxed reply deflects the question without revealing anything.
It suggests you’ve been casually pursuing them for a bit.

  • “Does it really matter at this point?”
  • “I honestly can’t remember…isn’t that crazy?”
  • “Would you have preferred I didn’t call at all?”
  • “A wise person once said ‘the how doesn’t matter.'”
  • “In the grand scheme of things, do the details really count?”
  • “You know what, I’m actually not certain myself!”
  • “Isn’t it more fun to have a little mystery?”
  • “Now why would I ruin the surprise by telling you?”
  • “I’m sure if you think really hard, you’ll figure it out!”
  • “The real question is…are you glad that I did?”

Embarrassed Replies

“Oh geez, you got me…I may have stalked you a little online.”

A dose of humble pie can be endearing!
Poking fun at yourself shows you don’t take things too seriously.
A sheepish response conveys you’re an approachable, down-to-earth person.

  • “I went through extreme, and possibly illegal, lengths.”
  • “You’ll have to forgive me, I get overzealous sometimes!”
  • “Does it help if I say I’m really good at internet sleuthing?”
  • “I’m actually a little fuzzy on the details…oops?”
  • “You’ve 100% caught me being a weirdo, I’ll own that!”
  • “I was scrolling through some old ‘missed connections’ posts…”
  • “Let’s just call it my patented ‘Thirsty Girl Method’ and leave it at that.”
  • “I’d explain but I’d only embarrass myself further.”
  • “Don’t hate the player, hate the game…or something like that!”
  • “I thought it would sound more romantic in person…”

Honest Answers

“A mutual friend passed it along. I hope that’s not too weird!”

If being upfront works better for you, honesty is the way to go!
Owning how you acquired their digits shows confidence.
A straightforward reply allows you to redirect the conversation.

  • “We have a few friends in common, so one of them hooked it up.”
  • “I noticed it listed in an old work directory and took a chance.”
  • “Barrett from Accounting never could keep a secret…”
  • “I found your number on an old account I was deactivating.”
  • “I might have done some strategically-placed flirting first!”
  • “Would you be upset if I admitted to finding it online?”
  • “You broadcaster seemed way too public, so I slid in!”
  • “I snagged it from the store’s customer sign-up sheet.”
  • “If I said I got it from the Landlord, would you be shocked?”
  • “Does the truth even matter at this point?”

Conspiracies & Mysteries

“I was sent from the future…to make sure you and I meet.”

For the skeptics who enjoy a healthy conspiracy theory, these are fun!
Weaving a tale of intrigue and secrets is unexpected and imaginative.
An elaborate scenario gets their mind exploring all the possibilities.

  • “You’ll have to consult with the Illuminati on that one.”
  • “If I told you, I’d have to recruit you into my cult.”
  • “Look, all I can say is…the Truth is Out There.”
  • “Let’s just call it ‘Alien Intervention’ and leave it at that.”
  • “Haven’t you heard? The squirrels are conducting surveillance.”
  • “I’m afraid this goes much higher than you and I…”
  • “For your safety, some things are better left unsaid.”
  • “I was sent by a radical anti-number privacy activist group.”
  • “Does the name ‘Deep Throat’ mean anything to you?”
  • “I’ll never reveal my secret…the number manipulators forbid it.”

Pop Culture References

“The real question is…have you ever danced with the devil in the pale moonlight?”

There’s nothing quite like bonding over shared interests!
Dropping some recognizable pop culture quotes creates instant rapport.
A clever reference tests their superfan status in a playful way.

  • “Did you put the screw in the tuna?” (Brooklyn Nine-Nine)
  • “How you doin’?” (Friends)
  • “An awfully hot coffee pot…” (Twin Peaks)
  • “This one time, at band camp…” (American Pie)
  • “I’ll make him an offer he can’t refuse.” (The Godfather)
  • “On a scale of 1 to 10, you’re a 9. And I’m the 1 you need.” (Clueless)
  • “Just smile and wave boys, smile and wave.” (Finding Nemo)
  • “Pizza in the morning is a food group!” (You’ve Got Mail)
  • Suns gettin’ real low…” (The Princess Bride)
  • “After all…he’s still a man from Nantucket.” (Family Guy)

Self-Deprecating Jokes

“Wow, you’re really calling me out on being a desperate loser here!”

If you can cheerfully poke fun at yourself, it’s very disarming.
A self-deprecating joke shows you’re comfortable in your own skin.
Using humor to acknowledge your flaws comes across as very human.

  • “Does this make me look like a stage 5 clinger?”
  • “I wore a fake delivery person disguise, go big or go home!”
  • “I have no shame when it comes to getting numbers, clearly.”
  • “To be fair, extreme thirstiness was absolutely involved.”
  • “Let’s just say there was a Craigslist posting for ‘Missed Connections.'”
  • “I only tracked down your info from a collection of old grocery lists.”
  • “I’ll save what’s left of my dignity and not disclose the sad truth.”
  • “I had to sell my soul to the internet goblin overlords to get it.”
  • “What can I say? I’m a professional stalker…of hotties only!”
  • “You know those spam phone numbers that call at 3am? I’m one of them!”

Classic Comebacks

“Let’s just say a little birdie owed me a favor!”

Some replies are tried-and-true for a reason – they’re delightfully cheesy!
Oftentimes, the silliest cliché lines are impossible not to laugh at.
Delivering a groan-worthy dad joke keeps the mood undeniably playful.

  • “I’m actually a secret admirer who has loved you from afar.”
  • “Your mom gave it to me, she’s a big fan of mine!”
  • “Your name hasn’t stopped ringing in my ears for weeks now.”
  • “I’m a man of many talents…number finding is just one.”
  • “No amount of truth could make this moment any more awkward.”
  • “Your caller ID just showed up in my psychic vision one day!”
  • “Didn’t you get the memo? I’m allowed to do what I want!”
  • “Let’s just say it was a happy accident of fate itself.”
  • “I may or may not have learned some magician sleight of hand skills.”
  • “Wouldn’t you like to know, Nosy Nancy…”

Replying to a Girl

When a girl asks how you got her number, you’ll want to tread carefully. Go for flirtatious yet respectful responses.

Lightly tease her with quips about her slipping you the digits or being irresistible. Keep things playful and complimentary, not overly sexual.

You can also take the coy route by being vague or changing the subject. This builds a fun air of mystery.

And if all else fails, a sprinkle of self-deprecating humor is always charming. Owning your “thirstiness” in a tongue-in-cheek way takes the pressure off.

Replying to a Guy

With a guy, witty banter and silly replies tend to go over best initially. Make jokes about psychics or trading your soul to get his number. Having an imaginative sense of humor creates common ground.

You can also be more direct by giving honest yet lowkey answers about mutual friends or online research. Just keep it casual and friendly.

If you sense receptiveness to flirtation, feel free to ramp up the boldness with saucy comments. But start mild to gauge his comfortability first.

Key Takeaways

  • Keep responses playful, lighthearted and not too serious
  • Craft comebacks that match your rapport and flirting style
  • Don’t be afraid to self-deprecate if it fits your humor
  • Find creative ways to deflect if you wish to be mysterious
  • Pay attention to cues for how direct or cheeky to be

Getting Their Digits Was Only Step One

Whether you go for humorous quips or smooth evasion, having some amusing replies ready is key.

Stay balanced between too spicy and too corny. As long as you tailor your comeback to their vibe, you’ll nail the perfect follow-up to score more banter!

Leave a Comment