Should You Say Happy Valentine’s Day to Your Crush? [No-BS Guide]

Valentine’s Day can be a total nightmare for those of us riding solo, am I right?

Getting bombarded with cringey couple posts and overpriced chocolate-covered everything…it’s enough to make a single person throw their phone out the window.

But let’s be honest, even in this modern hookup culture we live in, V-Day can also feel like the prime opportunity to finally confess your feelings for that special someone.

You know, your crush. That one person who makes your heart skip a beat whenever they walk into a room.

Maybe they’re that cutie from your yoga class, that funny coworker youlow-key flirt with by the coffee maker, or that ripped athlete you thirst over from afar at the gym.

Whoever they are, you can’t stop daydreaming about making a move.

Well, before you text them an ill-advised Valentine’s Day message you might regret, let’s break this down. Because making a move on your crush on V-Day is honestly a major gamble.

If things go well, hey, maybe you land yourself a hot Valentine’s date and finally get to smooch that special someone! But if it backfires…well, you could be fresh out of a crush and face-palming for months over your cringe-worthy actions.

I’m going to lay out the pros and cons to help you decide whether making your move on Valentine’s Day is a brilliant power play or just a terrible, terrible idea.

The Case For Saying Happy V-Day to Your Crush

First, let’s look at the positives. Because you know what? There are some legit reasons why Valentine’s Day could be the perfect time to shoot your shot:

It’s Romantic As Hell

Like it or not, everyone feels extra romantic and sappy on V-Day, even the big tough guy trying to act like he doesn’t care. The air is thick with hearts, roses, and cheesy love songs. It’s the kind of energy that could actually work in your favor!

If you’ve been holding a torch for someone, putting your feelings out there on the most romantic day of the year does make your crush seem more special. It’s like saying “You’re the one I want to be my Valentine.” Swoon!

Plus, your crush will probably be pleasantly surprised you decided to make a move on such a bold, romantic holiday. It immediately kicks things up a notch from “Hey, wanna grab drinks sometime?” to “Hey, I really like you. Like like like you.” For people who struggle with being direct about their feelings, V-Day can give you the perfect excuse.

Your Crush Might Be Looking For Love Too

Valentine’s Day has a weird way of making everyone crave romance and affection, even the most clueless people. You know those supposedly “oblivious” hunks who never bat an eye when you flirt with them? Well on February 14th, even they might finally clue into the fact that you’re into them!

Basically, if your crush is single, they’re probably feeling a little insecure, lonely, and touch-starved in the face of all that cloying couple stuff. So getting a flirty message from you might be exactly what they need to cheer them up. Suddenly their Valentine’s Day isn’t looking so sad and depressing anymore!

Whether your crush has been not-so-subtly eyeing you or they never took notice before, hearing that you’re their Valentine might finally pull their head out of the sand and make them see the amazing person who’s been pining over them all along.

You’ll Never Know Unless You Try

We hear it all the time, but it’s true: You miss 100% of the shots you don’t take. And in the game of love, someone has to be brave enough to make the first move.

So in that sense, Valentine’s Day is the perfect occasion to summon some courage and get those smoldering feelings off your chest. If you keep wishing and hoping without taking action, your crush will never realize there could be a spark between you two.

At the end of the day, you’ll never know if it could have worked out unless you’re bold enough to say something. And letting your crush know how you feel on V-Day? That’s the definition of bold!

Sure, rejection always risks a bit of embarrassment and heartbreak. But trust me, nothing stings quite like living the rest of your life always wondering what might have happened if you just worked up the nerve to take a chance.

Why Valentine’s Day Is A Terrible Time to Confess Your Feelings

Okay, now that we’ve looked at the perks, let’s keep it really real about the downsides. Because woah baby, there are some serious risks involved in dropping the “I really like you” bomb on V-Day:

You Could Ruin a Great Friendship

If your crush happens to be a good friend you really care about too, getting rejected after making a romantic gesture on Valentine’s Day is just…awkward AF. Things are bound to get incredibly tense and uncomfortable between you two for a while.

Frankly, it’s a messy situation no one needs. Your pal might even get freaked out imagining you pining over them for ages without them realizing, which can make it super weird just hanging out together normally like before.

Even if your crush takes the news gracefully and tries not to make it a big deal, there’s still a high chance your close friendship never feels quite the same again. At least not right away.

Do you really want to risk screwing up a valuable platonic bond over catching unexpected feelings? Maybe it’s wiser to just let an innocent crush remain an innocent crush, especially if you truly cherish your friend’s company long-term.

The Rejection Blues Will Hit HARD

In case you haven’t noticed, Valentine’s Day is pretty much designed to make single people feel miserable and alone. Now imagine the extra torture of not only being single on V-Day, but getting rejected by your crush too!

Having to deal with all that sappy romantic stuff by yourself plus the embarrassment and disappointment of getting turned down? Girl, it’s the makings of a total pity party trainwreck.

You may be tempted to lie on your couch eating ice cream straight from the carton and rage-watching sappy rom-coms in your bathrobe…for weeks. Not exactly a romantic way to spend your February! And March. And possibly April too.

Some wounds take longer to heal than others. But the harder you fell for your crush beforehand, the more devastating a V-Day rejection could feel. So brace yourself – the recovery period might be loooong.

While hopelessly pining over someone is painful enough, nothing hurts quite like being decisively rejected by them, especially after putting your heart on the line. It can leave you an insecure, self-doubting mess for a while.

Timing Is Everything

Here’s the tough truth: Valentine’s Day might be the worst possible time to tell someone you like them, because it can come across like you’re acting purely out of desperation.

Think about it. You wouldn’t want someone to confess feelings for you just because it’s Valentine’s Day and they’re lonely, right? You’d want them to like you for you, not just get caught up in all the obligatory romance hype surrounding the holiday itself.

Choosing V-Day to make a move may signal more about the cravings of the moment than any actual deeper feelings. And that timing factor could make your grand gesture come off as cheap, superficial, or even a little pathetic in your crush’s eyes.

After all, they might assume you’re just lonely on this Hallmark couple-y holiday and grasping at any opportunity for romance, whether it’s actually genuine or not. In that light, your heartfelt confession could get dismissed as nothing more than the thirsty horny ramblings of a desperate single person.

Yiiiiikes. That’s not exactly the impression you want to give the person you’re crazy about. So yeah, as far as timing goes, Valentine’s Day might turn out to be the worst choice for delivering your big “I like you” speech.

So, Should You Take The Risk?

Okay, enough analyzing the pros and cons! Let’s wrap this up already.

While there are some upsides to declaring your crush on V-Day, at the end of the day, most relationship experts would agree it’s a fairly risky, high-stakes move overall.

But hey, maybe that’s exactly the kind of boldness and courage you need to stand out from the crowd! Some people feel most alive when they’re putting it all on the line and letting the chips fall where they may.

If that adrenaline-junkie, nothing-to-lose mentality describes you and your romantic feelings are genuine – not just V-Day induced lust – well, go for it! Take a deep breath, muster up the courage, and make your move responsibly.

As in, don’t get sloppy drunk and text them a slew of X-rated emojis at 2am. Oof, cringe. Instead, you could try something sweet and low-pressure like:

“Hey [Crush’s Name], I know this might seem a little out of the blue, but I’ve been wanting to tell you for a while now – I have feelings for you and think you’re really special. Would you want to go out for dinner sometime on a real date?”

Leave the ball in their court while still making your intentions clear. No guilt trips, no getting bitter if they aren’t feeling the same way. If they say no, be cool about it!

However, if your feelings are more casual or you really can’t afford to risk an awkward friendship implosion right now, experts say it’s probably wiser to pass up shooting your shot on V-Day this year.

Either keep crushing from a distance for now or subtly test the waters by ramping up your flirting instead of rushing into a dramatic romantic confession. That way you can get a read on whether the interest might be mutual first.

At the end of the day, you know yourself and your unique situation best, so listen to your intuition. Most importantly, whenever you decide to put your feelings out there, make sure it’s for the right reasons at the right moment – not just because it’s freakin’ Valentine’s Day.

Alright you crazy kids, that’s it from me! Go make good choices, weigh those risks carefully, and above all else, have fun and stay true to yourself – whether you’re bravely shooting your shot or keeping your crush under wraps for now.

Happy Valentine’s Day! (Or not, lol.)


Leave a Comment