23 Modest Fall Outfits Stylish Conservative Looks for Autumn

Mrs And The Misc may earn commission from the links on this page, but we only ever share brands that we love and trust.

Sarah Koch

|

Ah, fall! The season of pumpkin spice lattes, cozy sweaters, and the eternal struggle to look cute while not freezing your butt off.

But fear not, my fashion-forward friends! I’ve teamed up with some of the savviest stylists in the biz to bring you 23 modest fall outfits that’ll have you looking like a autumn goddess without sacrificing your conservative values.

Trust me, I’ve been there. Trying to find that perfect balance between stylish and modest can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack. Or should I say, a cute turtleneck in a sea of crop tops?

So grab your PSL (basic, I know, but oh so good), and let’s dive into these fabulous fall looks that’ll have you feeling cozy, confident, and ready to take on the world – or at least that pile of leaves in your backyard.

Layered Turtleneck and Midi Skirt

Modest fall outfit with layered turtleneck and midi skirt

Who says you can’t be cozy AND chic? This look screams “I’m ready for a PSL run” while keeping things classy.

Pro tip: Add a statement belt to cinch that waist and add a pop of personality.

Oversized Sweater and Wide-Leg Trousers

Modest fall outfit with oversized sweater and wide-leg trousers

Comfort meets sophistication in this ensemble. It’s like wearing a hug while looking like you’ve got your life together.

Bonus: Those wide-leg trousers hide a multitude of sins. Thanksgiving food baby? What food baby?

Maxi Dress with Denim Jacket

Modest fall outfit featuring maxi dress and denim jacket

Channel your inner boho goddess with this flowy number. The denim jacket adds just the right amount of casual cool.

Remember: Twirling in a maxi dress is mandatory. It’s the law.

Turtleneck Sweater Dress and Knee-High Boots

Modest fall outfit with sweater dress and knee-high boots

One-piece dressing at its finest. This look says, “I woke up like this” (but actually put in effort).

Fun fact: Knee-high boots make everyone feel like a supermodel. Strut accordingly.

Plaid Blazer and Jeans

Modest fall outfit with plaid blazer and jeans

Embrace your inner Cher Horowitz with this classic combo. It’s giving “corporate chic meets weekend vibes”.

Don’t forget: Practice your hair flip. This outfit demands it.

Midi Sweater Dress and Chunky Sneakers

Modest fall outfit featuring midi sweater dress and chunky sneakers

Who says you can’t be comfy and cute? This look is perfect for those “I can’t even” days.

Remember: The chunkier the sneaker, the closer to God. Or something like that.

Turtleneck, Midi Skirt, and Tall Boots

Modest fall outfit with turtleneck, midi skirt, and tall boots

Sleek, sophisticated, and ready to take on the world (or at least the Starbucks line).

Pro tip: This outfit pairs well with a confident hair toss and a slight smirk.

Oversized Button-Down and Straight-Leg Trousers

Modest fall outfit with oversized button-down and straight-leg trousers

Channel your inner off-duty model with this effortlessly chic look. It’s giving “I just threw this on” (but make it fashion).

Remember: The messier the hair, the more “model off-duty” you look. It’s science.

Turtleneck Sweater and Corduroy Skirt

Modest fall outfit featuring turtleneck sweater and corduroy skirt

Texture mixing at its finest. This outfit screams “I’m ready for apple picking and Instagram photos”.

Don’t forget: A beret adds instant French girl chic. Oui oui!

Cardigan, Turtleneck, and Wide-Leg Jeans

Modest fall outfit with cardigan, turtleneck, and wide-leg jeans

Layer up in style with this cozy combo. It’s like wearing a blanket, but make it fashion.

Pro tip: The wider the jean, the more dramatic your walk. Work it, girl!

Sweater Vest Over Button-Down and Midi Skirt

Modest fall outfit with sweater vest, button-down, and midi skirt

Embrace your inner preppy princess with this academic-chic look. It’s giving “I aced my test and looked good doing it”.

Remember: Push up those sleeves for extra cool-girl points.

Turtleneck Bodysuit and High-Waisted Trousers

Modest fall outfit featuring turtleneck bodysuit and high-waisted trousers

Sleek, chic, and ready to conquer the world (or at least your to-do list).

Pro tip: A bold lip color takes this look from “meh” to “marvelous” in seconds.

Midi Wrap Dress and Ankle Boots

Modest fall outfit with midi wrap dress and ankle boots

Effortlessly elegant and oh-so-flattering. This look says, “I’m put together, but I didn’t try too hard”.

Remember: A wrap dress is basically a wearable hug. Embrace it.

Turtleneck Sweater and Pleated Midi Skirt

Modest fall outfit with turtleneck sweater and pleated midi skirt

This combo is giving major “sophisticated librarian who moonlights as a fashion blogger” vibes.

Don’t forget: Twirling in a pleated skirt is not just allowed, it’s encouraged.

Oversized Shacket and Skinny Jeans

Modest fall outfit featuring oversized shacket and skinny jeans

The perfect blend of cozy and cool. It’s like wearing your favorite blanket, but make it fashion.

Pro tip: The more oversized the shacket, the cooler you look. It’s a fact.

Turtleneck Poncho and Leggings

Modest fall outfit with turtleneck poncho and leggings

Comfort meets style in this boho-chic ensemble. Perfect for those “I want to be cozy but still look cute” days.

Remember: Dramatic hat tilts are encouraged with this look.

Midi Shirt Dress and Knee-High Boots

Modest fall outfit featuring midi shirt dress and knee-high boots

Effortlessly chic and perfect for those “I have my life together” vibes.

Pro tip: Roll up those sleeves for an extra dose of casual cool.

Turtleneck, Blazer, and Culottes

Modest fall outfit with turtleneck, blazer, and culottes

Business in the front, party in the back (of your legs). This look screams “I’m ready to conquer the boardroom and the bar”.

Remember: Swishing your culottes as you walk is not just fun, it’s a power move.

Ribbed Sweater Dress and Over-the-Knee Boots

Modest fall outfit featuring ribbed sweater dress and over-the-knee boots

Sexy yet modest, this look is perfect for those “I’m a lady in the streets” vibes.

Don’t forget: Walking in over-the-knee boots automatically makes you 10% more confident. It’s science.

Turtleneck, Pinafore Dress, and Tights

Modest fall outfit with turtleneck, pinafore dress, and tights

Channel your inner schoolgirl (but make it fashion) with this adorable ensemble.

Pro tip: Add a beret for extra French girl chic points.

Oversized Sweater and Leather Midi Skirt

Modest fall outfit featuring oversized sweater and leather midi skirt

The perfect blend of cozy and edgy. It’s like saying “I’m comfortable, but I could also kick your butt if needed”.

Remember: The messier the tuck, the cooler you look. Embrace the chaos.

Turtleneck Bodysuit and Corduroy Overall Dress

Modest fall outfit with turtleneck bodysuit and corduroy overall dress

Embrace your inner artsy girl with this textured combo. It’s giving “I paint on weekends and always carry a poetry book”.

Don’t forget: Messy buns are not just allowed, they’re encouraged with this look.

There you have it, folks! 23 modest fall outfits that’ll have you looking like a autumn goddess faster than you can say “pumpkin spice latte”. Now go forth and slay those falling leaves!

Remember, fashion is all about having fun and expressing yourself. So whether you’re rocking a turtleneck or twirling in a midi skirt, own it with confidence. After all, the best accessory is always a smile (and maybe a PSL in hand).

Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have a date with a chunky sweater and some apple cider. Fall, here I come!

Leave a Comment